Question Writing
Learning to write more complex questions will have a big
impact on exam quality
Many people believe that there serious limitations on what can be tested using multiple-choice
questions. Comments include: "how hard can a question be when the correct answer
is right in front of the person?" and "it is impossible to test a person on high-level
decision making using multiple-choice questions.
People who subscribe to this belief have not been properly trained on the principles
of writing quality multiple-choice questions. Apart from hands-on motor or sensory
skills, a properly designed multiple-choice question can assess any knowledge
or decision making process regardless of industry, cognitive complexity, or difficulty
level.
One type of multiple-choice question can assess terms, facts or principles directly
from a reference source. This type of question is characterized as a "recall" question.
Typically, these require the least amount of thought for the examinee to respond--either
they immediately know the answer or they are forced to guess. This type of question
is fine for testing simple "book knowledge," but falls short of assessing more complex
or higher-level decision making. As such, these questions should consist of less
than one-third the total number of questions on a high-stakes exam.
A more complex question type places examinees in a real-life situation or circumstance
that requires the recognition, selection, ordering or cause of job-related principles
or procedures. This type of question is referred to as an "Application" question,
and can take 2-3 times the amount of effort to develop recall questions. Application
questions should represent at least one-third the total number of questions on high-stakes
examinations.
The most complex type of questions called "Analysis" requires examinees to evaluate
information to discern fact from inference or assumption. Analysis questions often
contain graphs, charts, or tables of information and require the examinee to extract
relevant information from that which is irrelevant or erroneous. This type of questions
can take 5-10 times the amount of effort to develop recall questions. Nonetheless,
a well written high-stakes examination should have more than 20-30% of analysis
type questions.
Because untrained question writers find recall questions easiest to write, exams
tend to contain far too many of this type and not enough application or analysis
questions. As a result, the value of the examination in the eyes of candidates and
stakeholders drops because of an inability to assess the important components of
the job.
At Exam Design, we place great emphasis on training subject matter experts (SMEs)
to write high-quality multiple-choice questions. With the proper training contained
in ExamDeveloper, writers can become skilled in
writing questions that assess the entire range of knowledge and skills required
for competent job performance, not just those easily found in a book.
For organizations who prefer to use question types other than
multiple-choice, ExamDeveloper
can support many different types including hot-spot, drag and drop, true-false,
multiple response, case-based sets, and R-type questions.
Next Step
Which question types make the best exams?
Research shows that multiple-choice questions are the preferred exam format for
a wide variety of industries and content areas for a number of reasons.
First, multiple-choice exams can assess a wide variety of knowledge and skills if
designed properly. Second, multiple-choice exams can be developed by a large number
of subject matter experts with limited face-to-face interaction. Finally, multiple-choice
exams are less expensive to develop, administer, and score than formats such as
simulation and practical exams, as standardization is often more difficult to achieve
with those formats.
Our team of experts is experienced in developing exams in many formats, include
multiple choice, simulation, practical, design, and performance-based. Our experts
will help you understand the benefits of each format and will guide you toward the
most effective option for you, not the one most convenient or profitable for us.